Get Permission Kushwah, Jangid, Jain, and Mehta: A clinico-epidemiological study of cutaneous tuberculosis at tertiary care centre of western India


Introduction

The disease tuberculosis represents one of the oldest diseases encountered by humankind. Despite aggressive prevention programs, tuberculosis is still progressing endemically in developing countries and likewise other developing part of world, tuberculosis is continue to be in its grave form in the India. Cutaneous tuberculosis represents nearly 1.5% cases of extra-pulmonary tuberculosis. 1 Wide variation in clinical spectrum of cutaneous tuberculosis depends upon host immune status and portal of microbial entry. So we studied the incidence, clinical and histopathological features of cutaneous tuberculosis in our region. Early diagnosis and treatment of such cases at least make dermatologists as a part of the Great War against tuberculosis.

Materials and Methods

During the one year (September 2013 to September 2014) 34 newly diagnosed patients of cutaneous tuberculosis were included in this study, attending at the Dermatology Outpatient Department of Govt. Medical College and Hospital, Kota (Rajasthan, India). The demographic details, clinical andvaccination (BCG) history, family history and clinical features were recorded. Complete blood count (CBC), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), Montoux test, HIV (ELISA) test, Roentgenogramof chest and other regions (if indicated) and ultrasound of the abdomen were done. Complete blood count performed on blood analyser available in our medical college hospital. Montoux test is done using 5 TU of tuberculin solution injected intradermally and induration noted after 48-72 hr. Skin biopsies were sampled by 3mm punch from the active advancing edge of the lesion under aseptic conditions. Smear for acid fast bacilli (AFB) from lesion and sputum was done in each of the patients. Before the final diagnosis made by histopathological specimen some of the patients of newly diagnosed cutanenous tuberculosis were considered as psoriasis or eczema.

An ethical committee approval and written informed consent of study subjects was obtained.

Result

In our study, out of 1242 cases enrolled for tuberculosis, 278 cases were diagnosed as extra-pulmonary tuberculosis. Cutaneous tuberculosis represented only 2.73% (34 cases) of total and 12.23% of extra-pulmonary tuberculosis cases. The study consisted of 18 (52.94%) males and 16 (47.06%) females. The majority of patients were in the age group of 20 to 40 years (52.94%).

Lupus vulgaris (LV) (38.23%) was the most common morphological pattern of cutaneuos tuberculosis in our study followed by Scrofuloderma (SFD) (29.41%) and tuberculois verrucoa cutis (20.59%). Most of the patients (19 patients, 55.88%) had duration of less than one year specially in case of Scrofuloderma where 85.71% (6 out of 7cases) were present within one year(probably reflect its discharging nature of disease) Table 1). Family history of pulmonary tuberculosis was positive in 3 cases of Lupus vulgaris. Like wise past history of anti-tubercular treatment (ATT) was seen in 5 cases(2 cases of SFD and tubercular gumma each and one case of LV).

The commonest site of involvement was lower limbs seen in 12 (35.29%) patients followed by trunk 10 patients (29.41%) and face and neck in 9 patients (26.47%) (Table 2). In morphologic pattern, plaques were most common lesions in both tuberculois verrucoa cutis and lupus vulgaris while ulcerative lesions were in scrofuloderma. Lymphadenopathy was seen only in10 cases (eight cases of SFD and two cases of tubercular gumma) (Table 3). In most cases lesions were usually asymptomatic with occasional mild itching and complain of discharge (scrofuloderma).

Sputum was positive for AFB in three cases of scrofuloderma.Pulmonary symptoms of tuberculosis were seen in 11 patients (6 cases of SFD, 3 cases of LV and 2 cases of tubercular gumma). Caseation necrosis and epitheloid granuloma with Langhans giant cells were the most common histological finding (Table 4). X-ray findings suggestive of pulmonary tuberculosis were seen in 14 patients (six of SFD, four of LV, two of gumma and one for PNT and EIB each). Mantoux test was significantly positive (Table 5) as more than 15 mm in duration in fifteen cases (44.11%) and 10-15 mm in thirteen cases (38.23%), but negative in six cases(17.64%). ELISA test for HIV was positive in one case with multiple scrofuloderma.

Discussion

Tuberculosis can involve any organ or tissue of the body including skin. According to various studies worldwide incidence of tuberculosis is from 0.1 to 1% of all cutaneous disorders Bannerjee et al.,2 found 0.5% incidence, and LV, was seen commonest (38.29%), followed by TBVC(19.14%), scrofuloderma (14.89%), OFT in 14.89% and Tb gummas in 12.76%. In our study LV was the commonest morphological form followed by scrofuloderma and TBVC. Khan et al.,3 also found Lupus vulgaris the commonest form(50%) followed by TBVC (30%) and Scrofuloderma (20%). These results were also consistent with other Indian studies from different demographical areas7, 6, 5, 4 contrary to this Beyt et al., 8 Sehgal et al., 9 Yates and Ormerod, 10 Gopinathan et al., 11 and Yasmeen and Kanjee12 observed scrofuloderma, the commonest being varying from 40 to 65% respectively. Wong et al.,13 found TBVC the commonest 46% followed by LV 22%.

Scrofuloderma is a evidence of underlying tubercular focus which is extended to skin, it may be tubercular lyphadenitis or skeletal tuberculosis. SFD was seen in 10 (25%) of cases in our study. Scrofuloderma were found in only six cases out of which three had direct extension into the skin from cervical and two from axillary lymphadenitis.

In our study TBVC was seen in 7 (17.14%) of total cutaneous tuberculosis cases. In present study percentage of these cases were in higher number than the studies conducted by Yasmeen and Kanjee,12 Gopinathan et al.,11 and Ramesh et al.,14 who found it to be 8%, 13.17% and 14% respectively. Hands and fingers are most common site of involvement in westeren15 countries while in Eastern countries9 lower extremities involvement is observed.

OFT is the tuberculosis of the mucous membrane and the skin of the orifices resulting from auto inoculation of tubercle bacilli in patients with advanced visceral tuberculosis.16 Men are more often effected by it than women and middle-aged or older individuals are mostly get affected.16, 15 OFT is observed in only one case which was a 8 year male child. In our study 71.4% were males 40.28 years was the mean age that is consistent with of other studies done by various researchers.9, 6

Table 1

Age and sex distribution of various forms of cutaneous tuberculosis

Clinical variants Age groups Total
<20 years 20-40 years 40 years
Lupus vulgaris 2(2/0) 7(4/0) 4(0/4) 13
Scrofuloderma 1(1/0) 5(3/2) 4(0/4) 10
Tuberculosis verrucosa cutis 4(2/2) 3(3/0) 0 7
Tubercular gumma 0 1(1/0) 1(1/0) 2
Erythema induratum of Bazin 0 1(0/1) 0 1
Papulonecrotic tuberculid 0 1(1/0) 0 1
Total 7(20.59%) 18(52.94%) 9(26.47%) 34
Table 2

Site wise distribution in different types of cutaneous tuberculosis

Site → Face & Neck Upper limbs Trunk Lower limbs Genital Total(%
Clinical variants↓
Lupus vulgaris 5 1 5 2 0 13(38.23%)
Scrofuloderma 4 1 3 2 0 10(29.41%)
Tuberculois verrucoa cutis 0 0 0 7 0 7(20.59%)
Tuberculae gumma 0 0 2 0 0 2(5.88%)
Erythema induratum of Bazin 0 0 0 1 0 1(2.94%)
Papulonecrotic tuberculid 0 0 0 0 1 1(2.94%)
9 2 10 12 1 34
Table 3

Various morphologic pattern and lymphadenopathy

Clinical variants Plaque Ulcer Ulcero-plaque Tumor/Nodule Lymphadenopathy
Lupus vulgaris 10 0 3 0 0
Scrofuloderma 0 7 3 0 8
Tuberculois verrucoa cutis 7 0 0 0 0
Tuberculae gumma 0 0 0 2 2
Erythema induratumof Bazin 0 0 0 1 0
Papulonecrotic tuberculid 0 1 0 0 0
Table 4

The histopathological feature of cutaneous tuberculosis

Histopathological feature Number of cases Percentage
Caseation necrosis 17 50%
Tuberculoid granuloma with epitheloid and Langhans giant cells 24 70.58%
Epidermal hyperplasia 19 55.88%
Presence of AFB bacilli 6 17.64%
Table 5

Results of Mantoux test

Induration LV SFD TVC Tub.Gumma EIB PNT %
<10 mm 2 1 1 1 0 1 17.64
10-15 mm 9 1 2 1 0 0 38.23
>15 mm 2 1 11 0 1 0 44.11
Table 6

Major studies on cutaneous tuberculosis

Our study Puri N22 Patra AC et al.,18 Arora et al.,23 Thakur et al.,17 Terranova M et al.,21 Chaudhary et al.,20 Sharma S et al.,19
Study location /year Kota (2013-14) Punjab (2011) Kolkata (2006) Assam (2006) Assam (2012) North Ethiopia (2008) Pune (2012) Delhi (2015)
Study period 1 year NM 1 year 5 year 1 year 1 year 1 year 3 year
Sample size 34 30 104 37 42 202 46 165
M:F ratio 1:12 1.5:1 2.25:1 1.32:1
F/H NM NM
BCG (%) NM 59.6 35.7 100
Clinical types
LV 13 11(55%) (57.69%) 19 18 22(10.9%) 18(39.14) 85
SFD 10 5(25%) (21.15%) 6 21 143(70.8%) 14 (30.43) 39
TBVC 7 1(5%) (19.23%) 6 2 6(3%) 10 (20.74) 11
OFT 1 1(5%)
PNT 1 1(5%) 7 3(6.52) 3
EIB 2 1(5%) 2(1%) 2
LS 1 11(5.4%) 1(2.17) 24
Gumma 1 18(8.9%)
Extra CTB Hilar LN (1case) 14 22 34 16 36(21.8%)
Histopathology Tuberculoid granuloma Tb granuloma, epitheloid and langhans giant cells Granuloma Epitheloid granuloma Tuberculoid granuloma Epitheloid granuloma Tuberculoid granuloma Epitheloid granuloma
MT 28 10 (%) 98.07 27 (%) 35(%) 36(%) 85%
AFB smear NM 2 (SFD) 2(SFD) 143(SFD)
HIV 1 NR 7 NR 33 5
TX response Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good

Conclusion

Cutaneous tuberculosis is not a uncommon health problem found in our region. Due to different kind of clinicomorphological pattern and presentations there is difficulty in diagnosis of cutaneous tuberculosis. Delay in diagnosis can occur because scant attention is paid by elders during the early stages of the disease and when they seek advice it is often from practitioners little exposed to this uncommon condition. The lack of awareness is further heightened by the failure to mention skin involvement even in articles meant exclusively to educate practitioners about the different clinical types of tuberculosis and in special issues brought out to disseminate information on the various facets of this disease.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflicts of Interest

None declared.

Acknowledgment

Nil.

References

1 

Bhushan Kumar Ranju Rai Inderjeet Kaur Bijayalaxmi Sahoo Sivaram Muralidhar Bishan Das Radotra Childhood cutaneous tuberculosis: a study over 25 years from northern IndiaInd J Dermatol 20014012632

2 

B N Bannerjee Tuberculosis of the skin and its relation to pulmonary tuberculosisInd J Dermatol195726972

3 

Y Khan J Anwar P Iqbal A Kumar Cutaneous Tuberculosis A study of ten casesJ Pak Assoc Derma200111610

4 

B V Satyanarayan Tuberculoderma- a brief review together with statistical analysis and observationsInd J Dermatol Venereol1963292542

5 

G Singh Lupus vulgaris in IndiaInd J Dermatol Venereol19744025760

6 

B Kumar S Muralidhar Cutaneous tuberculosis: a twenty-year prospective studyInt J Tuberc Lung Disease19993494500

7 

S Dhar S Dhar Histopathological features of granulomatous skin diseases: an analysis of 22 skin biopsiesIndian J Derma2002478890

8 

B E Beyt D W Ortbals D J Santa Cruz G S Kobayashi A Z Eisen G Medoff Cutaneous tuberculosis: analysis of 34 cases with a new classification of the diseaseMed (Baltimore)19816095109

9 

V. N. Sehgal G. Srivastava V. K. Khurana V. K. Sharma P. Bhalla P. C. Beohar An Appraisal of Epidemiologic, Clinical, Bacteriologic, Histopathologic, and Immunologic Parameters in Cutaneous TuberculosisInt J Dermatol19872685216

10 

V M Yates L P Ormerod Cutaneous tuberculosis in Blackburn district (UK): a 15-year prospective series 1981-1995Br J Dermatol1997136483492

11 

L K Sengupta G Talukder A Sharma cell mediated immunity in cutaneous tuberculosisInd J Med Res19817374650

12 

N Yasmeen A Kanjee Cutaneous Tuberculosis: a three-year prospective studyJ Pak Med Assoc200555103

13 

K. O. Wong K. P. Lee S. F. Chiu Tuberculosis of the skin in Hong Kong: a review of 160 casesBr J Dermatol19688074249

14 

V. Ramesh R. S. Misra K. R. Beena A. Mukherjee A study of cutaneous tuberculosis in childrenPediatr Dermatol19991642649

15 

K Wolff G Tappeiner Fitzpatrick TB Eisen AZ Wolff K et al. eds Mycobacterial diseases: tuberculosis and atypical mycobacterial infections3McGraw HillNew York1987215286

16 

S L Moschella Mycobacterial infectionsDermatology. 2nd edWB SaundersLondon

17 

BinodKumar Thakur Shikha Verma Debeeka Hazarika A clinicopathological study of cutaneous tuberculosis at Dibrugarh district, AssamIndian J Dermatol2012571635

18 

Ramesh Chandra Gharami Paritosh K Banerjee Apares Chandra Patra A profile of cutaneous tuberculosisIndian J Dermatol20065121057

19 

Sonal Sharma Virendra N. Sehgal Sambit N. Bhattacharya Garima Mahajan Richa Gupta Clinicopathologic Spectrum of Cutaneous Tuberculosis: A Retrospective Analysis of 165 IndiansAm J Dermatopathol201537644450

20 

N D Chaudhari H V Talaniker P Deshmukh S Gupta A clinicopathological study of cutaneous tuberculosis at Pune district, MaharashtraInt J Pharm Biomed Sci2012341813

21 

Margherita Terranova Valeska Padovese Ugo Fornari Aldo Morrone Clinical and Epidemiological Study of Cutaneous Tuberculosis in Northern EthiopiaDermatol200821718993

22 

N Puri A clinical and histopathological profile of patients with cutaneous tuberculosisIndian J Dermatol20115655502

23 

S Arora G Arora S Kakkar Cutaneous Tuberculosis : A Clinico-morphological StudyMed J Armed Forces India20066243447



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File  


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/ 10.18231/j.ijirm.2020.003


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 1924

PDF Downloaded: 607